Pinocchio’s pepperoni pizza builds on the same medium-thick crust and tomato base as the cheese pie, adding a layer of curled, crisp-edged pepperoni slices. The fat from the pepperoni renders as the pizza bakes, seasoning the cheese and edges of the crust. Each slice brings a mix of salty, slightly spicy meat with gooey cheese and a satisfying chew from the dough. Many guests mention this as their standard order for sharing with a group or watching a game at one of the tables.